Reviews

Leica M5 Review by Jake Horn

The Leica M5 has been in my collection for quite some time. I have used it hear and there on different occasions. It was only recently that I started taking it on all of my non-landscape photography trips. I got inspired to find a camera that would meter with my Voigtlander 15mm SL Nikon F-mount lens. It occurred to me that this wide angle can be easily installed on a M-mount via an adapter, but would there be enough room to fit without interfering with the M5’s light meter? Or even worse cause physical damage to the CDS cell, as this is an invasive lens.

SPECS:

  • WEIGHT = 699g

  • DIMENSIONS = 148x80x33mm (LxWxH)

  • FINDER = 0.72x Magnification

  • POWER = 1.35V Mercury-Oxide Battery (Weincell MRB625)

  • METER = Spot, Through the Lens (TTL)

Offered in both silver and black chrome, as well as a 50th anniversary edition. More black units were produced (23,150) than the silver version (10,750).

PROS:

After receiving my Nikon-F to M-Mount adapter, I started to make some careful depth measurements. Consequently, I found that I could mount the 15mm SL on the M5 with 3mm of clearance to the light sensor, which pops up behind the lens. Finally, a camera that will meter properly with my Voigtlander!

This prompted me to shoot more often with the combo. As I shoot more and got comfortable with the body, I find the size to be a positive. While shooting with traditional Leica rangefinders (M2, M3, etc.), my right fingers reach almost to the lens barrel which feels a little awkward. The taller/wider body of the M5 allows for different, comfortable hand placements.

I enjoy having the option to attach a strap in the horizontal or vertical configuration. There is also an earlier, two lug version. My favorite ergonomic touch is the shutter speed dial. As it slightly overhangings the body, you can adjust very easily with one finger while looking through the finder. And the finder is terrific with bright, thick frame lines.

CONS:

My hesitation to choose the M5 over other cameras for travel is the weight. Compared to the M2, it’s 23% heavier. I probably would never take this on backpacking trips, but the extra heft is not that noticeable on city walks and road tripping.

Although having the light meter is the biggest positive for me, there are a few caveats to keep in mind. First is that the meter will not operate properly if the body is in portrait orientation. The other is that any downward pressure on the shutter release can affect the reading. This is due to the mechanical operation of the sensor moving out of the way of the image circle as the shutter is pressed.

One last issue on the meter, which only impacts those who own collapsible lenses, is that many CAN NOT be stowed in the collapsed position without damage to the meter. Old Leica literature actually states cementing the lens extended to insure no accidental damage.

BOTTOM LINE:

Just an outstanding camera with tremendous build quality. Not sure if I would use it often without the benefit of metering with my 15mm. But I think that’s why the M5 has its love it or hate it reputation. You really need a test drive before diving into ownership. The size and ergonomics is something that may or may not click when you have it in hand. But I think it’s still worth a look for anyone wanting for a competent, meter equipped, Leica.

SAMPLE:

Leica M5 | 15mm/4.5 | Adox CMS 20 II